CAPE COD, NOVEMBER, 1620
WILLIAM BRADFORD: Captain Jones, where are we? What land is this?
CAPTAIN JONES: This is Cape Cod, in what our map calls "New England." We are in shallow water, and we risk being shipwrecked. We are anchoring here.
JOHN CARVER: Cape Cod? What are you talking about? We're supposed to land in Virginia. In heaven's name, get us out of here. Pull up the anchor, and get on to the Hudson's River.
[The island of Manhattan, at the outlet of the Hudson River, was at the northern edge of the Virginia Company's territory.]
CAPTAIN JONES: I am sorry, Mr. Carver, but this looks like a safe harbor. We have been at sea for many weeks. My men are sick and tired and need rest. The sea is stormy, and winter is near. You are going to have to forget about Virginia. This is where the Mayflower stays.
THOMAS TINKER: The charter says we land in Virginia. I say let's go on to Virginia.
OTHER VOICES: On to Virginia. Let's get away from this cold, dreary place.
PETER BROWNE: Look at that shore. There's nothing on it. It doesn't look fit to grow anything. Is this where we're supposed to live? Who among you wants to die in this wilderness?
VOICES: Not I! Not I! Let's go on to Virginia!
BRADFORD: Captain Jones says we are staying here. We have no choice. We cannot sail the Mayflower without a captain and crew.
CARVER: We must be thankful to be in America. We will make our homes here.
[Murmurs of discontent.]
WILLIAM BREWSTER: Let us not forget how good God has been to us. He brought us to America. He protected us; only one of us died at sea. We will prosper here and be happy.
BROWNE: We're not listening to you.
TINKER: Wait. It may not be such a bad idea to land here.
RICHARD GARDINER: What do you mean?
TINKER: We have a charter for land in Virginia - not in New England. If we land here, outside Virginia, our contract with those greedy merchants in London will not matter. You all know how unhappy we were when they insisted that all profits be shared in common for the first seven years.
GARDINER: That's true. They refused to let us work two days a week for ourselves or even to keep a private garden. It would serve them right if we stop here!
VOICES: We'll show them. Let's stay here!
BRADFORD: It would appear that we have little choice in any event. But this is a harsh land, and we face many dangers. Surely there are savages nearby. For our own protection, we must set up a system of government to take the place of our patent, our grant, from the company.
VOICES: Why bother? Who needs government? Every man for himself
TINKER: You Pilgrims are in a majority. You can dominate any government we set up. I don't think that's fair.
BRADFORD: We're all in the same boat, Pilgrims and Strangers together. Surely as children of God we can work this out. If we don't stand together, the savages may well wipe us out.
CAPTAIN STANDISH: Quiet, men. Listen to Bradford and Carver. They know what they are talking about. You know me; I'm not a Pilgrim. I'm a soldier. Let them explain what they want to do.
[John Carver holds up a paper.]
TINKER:What's that?
BRADFORD: We have thought a great deal about what is the fair thing to do for all here. We have written a document for all men to sign. We will agree to set up our own government, with equal laws for everyone. And all must pledge to obey the laws that we shall make.
BROWNE: Why do we need laws? We've come here to escape bad laws.
CARVER: Exactly. But we must make good laws to take their place. A community cannot exist without laws. Laws will help us make sure that everyone lives safely, happily, and peacefully together.
TINKER: You say "we" must do this and laws will help "us." I suppose by that you mean only the Pilgrims.
CARVER: No, no. We mean every adult male in the colony.
GARDINER: Sounds fair to me. I think we have a new charter that we can all live with. I will sign it.
STANDISH: Men, let Mr. Carver and Mr. Bradford sign first.
[A majority of the men - 41 - sign the compact.]
BROWNE: We've forgotten something. We need a leader. Who will lead us?
GARDINER; Here's our first chance to vote. Let's decide among ourselves who will be our first governor,
VOICE: I nominate John Carver as the first governor.
VOICE: I second the nomination.
[John Carver is overwhelmingly elected the first governor.]
STANDISH: Volunteers for the first landing party over here! Let's see what this Cape Cod looks like!