Mansfield's Water Mains Failing Infrastructure that affects the whole community; and a community driven solution that may fix it

Whether it is being used in homes, businesses, or in public spaces, readily available water is a key component to a well functioning community. One area it is absolutely vital is during fire emergencies.

During a fire emergency, firefighters will arrive on the scene and tap into the closest fire hydrant available and begin dowsing the fire with water. What happens though, if the closest fire hydrant available does not work?

Today Mansfield has a problem, a problem that started during the early 1900's when Mansfield's water main infrastructure was built. Out of the 321 miles of water main infrastructure in Mansfield, 60 miles of it are deteriorating due to aging and corrosion. Currently, there are 385 fire hydrants that do not work or are inadequate of providing enough water to firefighters because they are too small and corroded; affecting around 2,400 addresses in the city of Mansfield. (1) (Photo courtesy of Blair McClenathan)

A corroded pipe. Photo courtesy of Blair McClenathan.

In 2023 Mansfield Firefighters responded to 71 building fires. That is a scary number to think about when considering the fact that many of Mansfield's fire hydrants are not fully functioning. Mansfield Fire Chief Dan Crow has spoken on the issue. According to Crow, the first 5 to 10 minutes are the most crucial when dealing with a building fire. Therefore, if firefighters arrive on the scene and the closest fire hydrant does not work, firefighters will have to spend invaluable time finding another hydrant to use, which could be hundreds of feet away. "That does create a hindrance because, as we arrive, we're finding situations where we have to abandon that closest hydrant and look for another water main that has sufficient water," he said. "It does impact us considerably." (2)

"It does impact us considerably."
Fire Chief Dan Crowe, the Mansfield Central Fire Station, and Mansfield firefighters responding to a call.

This is concerning, because having inadequate fire hydrants is a health and safety risk in the community, so what can be done about it?

Out of service fire hydrants in Mansfield.

The Mansfield Water Main Initiative is a citizen-led initiative that proposes a 4-year, 0.25% income tax on citizens and workers in Mansfield that would generate 17 - 18 million dollars towards fixing water mains (3). This income tax is proposed by citizens, this means that the city of Mansfield can only use the money from the income tax for the purposes of fixing the water mains, otherwise citizens may sue the city for misappropriation. An important note is that this tax would not affect retired individuals, and only applies to earned income, not investments. There are no federal or state grants that will provide funds to fix this issue, therefore this is the only funding option available.

A page of a Mansfield Water Main Initiative brochure. Photo courtesy of The Mansfield Water Main Initiative.

The issue of Mansfield's fire mains has been on the mind of Eric Miller, Treasurer of the Mansfield Water Main Initiative, since about 2008. What he explained was that while citizen-led efforts were being made at that time to address this issue, the Great Recession of 2008 slowed things down. The reason, he says, for the lack of awareness around this issue is because infrastructure is an issue that is historically neglected; it is an issue that people tend to push down the road further and further, until it cannot be ignored. He adds that, by kicking this issue further down the road, it could be passing its consequences down to our next generation of citizens. According to the American Council of Engineering Companies of Ohio, Mansfield has a D+ rating in drinking water infrastructure, due to water mains experiencing water losses greater than 35%, with water line breaks projected to increase in some areas by 36%. The economic affect this has cannot be overstated, because without water many businesses cannot function, and unfortunately a water main is not easy to replace, it requires manpower, special equipment, and time; in short, it takes money, and piecemeal repairs are not cost efficient.

Eric Miller, alongside a letter from the ACEC, and local business owner Brian Schmidt.

How would this tax impact the average Mansfield household? According to Data USA, the average annual household in Mansfield, Ohio, is $37,000 (4). This means that the average household will pay $92.50 per year to fund this initiative. A small price to pay for such an important issue.

For Mansfield's water main issue to be solved, money must be raised to adequately replace the old infrastructure. I believe this income tax will be beneficial, as it addresses a crucial health and safety risk in the Mansfield community. This initiative will be on the ballot March 19. If you are a resident of Mansfield, or work in Mansfield, I encourage you to express your feelings on the topic by voting this upcoming March.

Let's make Mansfield's fire hydrants functional, not just stylish

References:

1. Mansfield Water Main Initiative. https://mansfieldwatermaininitiative.com/

2. Caudill, Mark. Jan. 12, 2024. City fire chief reviews importance of water mains at public forum. Mansfield New Journal. https://www.mansfieldnewsjournal.com/story/news/local/2024/01/12/mansfield-ohio-fire-chief-dan-crow-water-main-issues-public-forum/72164243007/

3. Hunnel, Carl. Oct. 18, 2023. Mansfield Water Main Initiative: ‘We’re running out of time’. Richland Source. https://www.richlandsource.com/2023/10/18/mansfield-water-main-initiative-were-running-out-of-time/

4. DataUSA. https://datausa.io/profile/geo/mansfield-oh